An edited version of this story first appeared in DNA main edition on Monday, December 31, 2012.
Media is not only the mirror of the society, it also shapes the society. "While mirroring part is taken very seriously," feels Prasoon Joshi, president, McCann Worldgroup South Asia, "shaping is not and that's what I end up arguing with most media professionals including a few who are good friends."
Media, including the film and advertising fraternity, is often accused of commodifying women. There have been several instances of objectionable advertisements, portrayal of women in bad taste by a section of the fraternity. However, industry players feel putting everyone in the same basket is incorrect.
According to Joshi, such people exist in both the advertising and film fraternity. "You find all kinds of films, people and portrayals. Some people actually are very careful about it and would not try and objectify a women or unduly disrespect or degenerate her image. But at the same time there would be others who don't care and bother. As a result you see advertisements and films with objectionable content," said Joshi adding, it is for this reason there are various bodies to regulate such a mindset.
Media has been regarded as reflection of the society and mirror's what it sees across cultures in its communication and messages. While media has to be responsible and understand their limitations, it cannot hide facts. That said, Media also needs to follow certain rules, have a line of control, but some entities do go overboard in an attempt to play the TRP game.
Media is not only the mirror of the society, it also shapes the society. "While mirroring part is taken very seriously," feels Prasoon Joshi, president, McCann Worldgroup South Asia, "shaping is not and that's what I end up arguing with most media professionals including a few who are good friends."
Media, including the film and advertising fraternity, is often accused of commodifying women. There have been several instances of objectionable advertisements, portrayal of women in bad taste by a section of the fraternity. However, industry players feel putting everyone in the same basket is incorrect.
According to Joshi, such people exist in both the advertising and film fraternity. "You find all kinds of films, people and portrayals. Some people actually are very careful about it and would not try and objectify a women or unduly disrespect or degenerate her image. But at the same time there would be others who don't care and bother. As a result you see advertisements and films with objectionable content," said Joshi adding, it is for this reason there are various bodies to regulate such a mindset.
Media has been regarded as reflection of the society and mirror's what it sees across cultures in its communication and messages. While media has to be responsible and understand their limitations, it cannot hide facts. That said, Media also needs to follow certain rules, have a line of control, but some entities do go overboard in an attempt to play the TRP game.
"One tends to see a few instances of women being commoditised on television channels for high TRPs," said Raj Kamble, managing director, Strawberryfrog. "But the audience these days are smart enough and hence do not take them seriously. I can confidently say that a large section of media these days does a lot of sensible things and that's very commendable."
While there is no denying on media being the reflection of the society, is it really doing enough to bring in that much required a change? With atrocities happening time and again, is there a need for introspection in their approach to projecting women in a manner that instills a sense of confidence in addition to providing a safe and secure way of life for women in the country.
"Introspection is necessary anytime some atrocities happen. It should not be restricted only to the advertising and film fraternity but every other place, fraternity, discipline where there are women. They are all part of a society and media can not be singled out as the reason why this is happening or has happened," said Joshi.
Indian psyche, experts feel, is among the various reasons responsible for problems to occur. Nothing happens suddenly as it could be part of a larger consciousness of this country. "It's not as if the film makers in this era are responsible. To be fair, advertisements or films in the past have showcased women in a different light. You can go back and find things that are objectionable throughout," said a media professional.
What is it that can bring change then? The whole consciousness of the society needs to reject something which is objectionable, feels the media fraternity.
"One must understand that advertising or film is also a product. People should get conscious if there is something not acceptable and stop buying than looking upon it. No matter how much people consume pornography, people don't consume and accept it openly. If there is something that's objectionable to women, it should not be the decision of a few people of the society. A larger consciousness of the nation has to reject it," said Joshi.
He added, "When we talk about "dowry" or something like "sati", which is a thing of the past now, those are also part of our tradition and we have realised those are things we have to do away with. Larger consciousness of the society has rejected it and that is the approach really required today."
A section of the fraternity feels that advertising and films are about creating images and it would not be fair to single them out or hold responsible. "Media is a very easy target but there are many hidden layers in the society that are shaping this concept," said a media professional.
"If there is a fashion product and someone is walking the ramp, wearing a certain kind of dress and is very confident about herself, that is what needs to be looked at. Ye thodi ki, bori mein lapet ke aurat ko bitha dein... We have to respect her individuality, dreams and freedom of expression. If she wants to go out on her own she should be able to do that," he added.
Commenting on safety measures for girls/ women in various Indian cities, the fraternity is convinced that one cannot imagine a girl / women anywhere in the country saying that she wanted to watch a movie, bought the ticket and sat in the theatre all by herself. "Very rarely one would find a young girl alone in such public places. I hate people who say why did you go alone. What the hell? What are we talking about, what society are we talking about," said a top media professional with a leading advertising agency in Mumbai.
Secondly, in case of rape we have to remove one very important perception - that the women has been shamed. Why should she be shamed? It is the man who should be shamed. In fact the society should ostracise the rapist. Instead the rapist are celebrating and sitting in various powerful positions in the country. How can we let that happen? Everytime something like this happens, the victim has to go hide her face somewhere and the people who have done it are proudly roaming around in the society. Why such double standards?
"I consider today is a very positive phase because people like you and me are openly talking about it. It's a fact that people have never ever looked at rape so seriously in the past. That fact that people including media are asking questions, there is a sensitivity towards it, there is questioning attitude towards it. The fact that we are ready to introspect. I think it's a very positive sign," said Joshi.
No comments:
Post a Comment